The History of Early Coffeehouses in the United States

Monis Bukhari
3 min readApr 23, 2024

--

Through British colonists in the 17th century, coffee made its way to become an integral part of the cultural, social, and economic life in the United States. From historic coffeehouses that were centers of discussion and thought to the emergence of specialty chains that helped introduce espresso drinks to the masses. Coffee has played a pivotal role in shaping the nation’s identity and the evolution of its culture.

The Beginnings of American Coffee Culture

The British introduced coffee to the New World in the mid-17th century, with the first licensed American coffee house established in Boston, Massachusetts by John Sparry in October 1676. However, Dorothy Jones was the first licensed coffee trader in the U.S., selling coffee from her tavern as early as around 1670. These early establishments were not mere places to grab a cup of coffee; they were hubs of social, political, and economic activity. For example, the organization that later became the New York Stock Exchange originated in the Tontine Coffee House on Wall Street in Manhattan.

Coffeehouses as Cultural Hubs

In the 1950s and 1960s, Italian-style coffeehouses began appearing across North America, featuring folk and Americana music. These venues served as important cultural scenes, fostering interaction between audiences and artists. Due to their small size and lack of alcohol, these coffeehouses often didn’t require formal licenses, making them accessible venues for performances and gatherings. They provided an excellent launching pad for new talent and allowed traveling artists to make a living through informal booking arrangements.

Caffè Lena: A Landmark in Coffeehouse History

Caffè Lena in Saratoga Springs, New York, holds the title of the oldest continually operating coffeehouse in the United States, founded in 1960 by William and Lena Spencer. It has hosted a wide range of artists, from Bob Dylan to Ani DiFranco, and remains a prominent venue for folk music and emerging artists.

The Evolution of Coffee Consumption

The Boston Tea Party of 1773 was a pivotal moment in American history, leading to a collective shift from tea to coffee among colonists that forever changed the nation’s coffee culture. Coffeehouses played a role in both the American and French Revolutions, serving as centers for public discourse and thought. The Civil War further boosted coffee consumption.

American coffee culture has evolved through several “waves”. The first wave was about convenience, as coffee became a mass-produced commodity. The second wave introduced variety and the rise of franchise giants like Starbucks, bringing espresso drinks to the masses. The third wave focused on the artistry of coffee making, highlighting bean varieties, roast profiles, flavors, and origins. The current fourth wave seeks to demystify the coffee creation process and promote community education.

Caffe Reggio: A Historic Coffeehouse

Caffe Reggio, founded in 1927 in Greenwich Village, Manhattan, New York City, is the oldest continually operating coffeehouse in the United States. It stands as a testament to the enduring legacy of coffeehouses in American culture.

From the first coffeehouse in Boston to the cultural institution of Caffè Lena, coffeehouses in the United States have played a significant role in shaping the social and cultural fabric of the nation. They have been the birthplace of grand ventures, a platform for artists, and a space for political and intellectual discourse. As American coffee culture continues to evolve, these establishments remain an integral part of the nation’s identity and daily life.

References

Coffee Houses in America: A Brief Analysis

A Brief History Of American Coffee Culture

Coffeehouses: Folk Music, Culture, and Counterculture

--

--

Monis Bukhari

Arab researcher, passionate about culinary history, geography, and social history. Uzbek, raised in Syria, resides in Germany. With Arab-Turk roots.